Quick links: Rugby Video | Six Nations Rugby | Premiership Rugby | LV= Cup | Rugby Championship | Heineken Cup Rugby | Pro 12 Rugby | Super Rugby | Currie Cup Rugby | Rugby World Cup
 
 
 

In Rugby, size does count after all


Email Article | | Print Article | Click here for a free $150 Bet

Article Published: Tuesday 21 February 2012


Rugby fans who say the modern game is being dominated more and more by heftier players and pumped iron can point to scientific evidence to back their case.

Teams with the tallest backs and heaviest forwards are the likeliest to win the World Cup, according to a study by French researchers published on Tuesday.

Adrien Sedeaud of the Institute of Sports Biomedicine and Epidemiology in Paris collected data for the age, weight and height for 2,692 players who took part in World Cup matches between 1987 and 2007, and compared this with their team's performance.

The players were divided into 1,457 forwards (numbers one to eight) and 1,235 backs (nine to 15).

Throughout the 20-year period under study, the weight of all players progressively increased by more than 6.6 kilos (14.5 pounds). In height, forwards were 0.6 centimetres taller (a quarter of an inch) over 20 years, and backs 1.09 cms (0.4 inches).

But the difference was startling among the teams that reached the quarters, semis and finals.

On average, forwards and backs among these high-performing sides were some two kilos (4.4 pounds) than the other teams.

Their backs were taller by around two centimetres (0.8 inches), although there was little height difference among forwards.

Bigger did not mean fatter, though. A more intense training regime and rigorous nutritional regime led to more muscle, for speed and strength, over the two decades.

The change to bigness began with the advent of professionalism in 1995, which created a more high-intensity sport with more rucks, mauls and tackles per game among its forwards, says the paper.

Yet the more mobile game has also required greater endurance and speed among its backs, it says.

"The maximisation of builds and the quest for 'supersizes' are inherent to international-level rugby as in other sports," it says.

The 2011 Cup, which is not covered in the study, had a final with two teams that were almost identical in terms of pack weight.

France's forwards weighed 903 kilos (1,986 pounds), and New Zealand's 902 kilos (1,984 pounds). New Zealand edged France by a single point, 8-7.

Even so, size is not everthing.

Winning teams also had more collective experience among their forwards, determined as the percentage of players who had played in previous World Cups. In teams who hoisted the trophy, this was nearly 40 percent, compared with under 32 percent for other teams.

"Collective experience of forwards gives a clear advantage during phases of collective combat," says the paper, published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine. "The art of working together, sharing the action either on offence or defence, is the essence of rugby."

Only four teams -- New Zealand, Australia, South Africa and England -- have ever won the global trophy, an elite group that indicates that there are intangible factors in success, says Sedeaud.

"Winning teams in a Rugby World Cup may also owe their victory to their nation's economic, historical, political and technological investment in this sport."

 
 
Heineken Cup Rugby News
Armitage slapped with 12 week ban for misconduct
Toulon fullback Delon Armitage has been given a 12 week suspension for unsportsmanlike behaviour in his team's 25-21 loss to Leicester Tigers at Welford Road in the European Rugby Champions third Round.
Read more on this Rugby news article

Other recent news
Castrogiovanni fined and has ban suspended
Harlequins lock Matthews could face one year ban
Wasps depart Adams Park with big Castres victory

More Heineken Cup Rugby News

Aviva Premiership
Former Wallaby captain Horwill to join Harlequins
English Premiership Rugby club Harlequins have announced that they have signed former Australia captain James Horwill on a three year deal following the 2015 Rugby World Cup
Read more on this Rugby news article

Other recent news
Leicester re-sign Youngs, Cole and Ayerza
Waldrom wins Premiership player of the month
Wasps set to break Premiership attendance record

More Aviva Premiership News

Anglo Welsh Cup News
Cardiff down Scarlets in Anglo Welsh LV= Cup
Cardiff Blues secured their second Anglo Welsh LV= Cup victory when they beat fellow Welsh side the Scarlets at the Arms Park on Friday night.
Read more on this Rugby news article

Other recent news
Dragons upset Ospreys in Anglo Welsh LV Cup
Leicester come from behind to beat Sale Sharks
Wasps down Exiles for first LV Cup victory

More Anglo Welsh Cup News

Six Nations Rugby
Under fire Johnson gets backing from bosses
Scottish Rugby Union chief executive Mark Dodson has denied claims that Scott Johnson has been rewarded for failure after Scotland's miserable 2014 Six Nations campaign.
Read more on this Rugby news article

Other recent news
England's Brown wins Six Nations best player
Scotland fullback Hogg gets three week ban
Warburton to be out of action for 'several months'

More Six Nations Rugby News

 
Rugby Week Sponsor
 
 
Latest Rugby video